NFL kickers missed 71 extra-point kick tries during the 2015 season — 63 more than they missed in the entire 2014 regular season.
Last offseason, the league adopted a Competition Committee proposal to move the spot from where the ball is snapped on PAT kick tries back to the 15-yard line, making what was a 20-yard kick a more challenging 33-yard kick.
“The decision didn’t happen overnight,” said Senior Vice President of Officiating Dean Blandino. “The Committee has been looking at this for several seasons.”
As kickers have become more accurate, the extra point became almost automatic; in 2014, NFL kickers converted 99.3 percent of extra-point kick tries. Kicking from the longer distance in 2015 resulted in more misses, with placekickers connecting on only 94.2 percent of extra-point kick tries (1,146/1,217).
The Committee reviewed data and discussed various ways to make the play less automatic and more exciting. Longer kicks were tested during the Hall of Fame Game and the first two weeks of the 2014 preseason.
The proposal the Committee presented to the owners this offseason not only moved the kick back, but also kept the 2-point tries at the 2-yard line and allowed defenses to return missed tries. The rule change passed by a 30-2 margin and was implemented before the 2015 season.
“The change has had the desired effect,” said Blandino. “The play is not automatic anymore.”
NFL teams went for two a record 94 times in 2015
When the NFL moved extra-point kick tries back to the 15-yard line, making what was a 20-yard kick a more challenging 33-yard kick, the hope was that the longer kick would tempt teams into attempting more 2-point tries.
The league moved the ball back to the 15-yard line on extra-point tries, but it kept the spot of the ball at the 2-yard line on 2-point conversions to further entice coaches into going for two more often.
The experiment did increase the number of attempts, with NFL teams attempting a record 94 2-point conversions after touchdowns, but coaches still opted to try an extra-point kick 92 percent of the time — or after 1,217 of the 1,318 touchdowns scored in 2015.
In 2015, teams converted on 48 percent of their attempts — or 45 times. That is about the same rate as in 2014, when teams converted 47 percent of their attempts (28/59).
Pittsburgh Steelers head coach Mike Tomlin embraced the change and went for two more than any other coach this season, attempting 11 2-point conversions and successfully converting eight times.
NFL Football Operations’ mission is to establish a culture of clarity, consistency and credibility in all aspects of the greatest game. Football is an essential piece of America’s fabric, uniting fans, players and communities with a simple yet powerful bond. We honor the game’s history while continuing to innovate and preserve the sport for future generations of fans, players, coaches, teams and officials.